|
Sex Between Therapist and Patient is NEVER Acceptable
Most counselors and psychotherapists are
responsible, ethical professionals who work for the benefit of their clients. However,
sometimes therapists have problems of their own which can result in impaired judgement and
may lead them to become sexually involved with their patients.
EVERY MENTAL HEALTH PROFESSION'S CODE OF
ETHICS CONTAINS A SPECIFIC PROHIBITION AGAINST THERAPIST-PATIENT SEXUAL INVOLVEMENT.
WHY IS SEX BETWEEN THERAPIST AND CLIENT
EXPLOITATION?
By its nature, the therapeutic relationship
is unequal. Clients make themselves vulnerable by sharing intimate details of their lives
with their therapists. Patients invest trust and authority in therapists, relying on the
therapist's judgement for help. Often, clients view their therapists as powerful, parental
figures, and patients may interact with the counselor in a child-like way. Many clients
idealize, admire, and experience sexual attraction or romantic feelings toward their
therapists.
Competent, ethical therapists recognize that these client responses are
normal, but they also realize that the power imbalance between therapist and
patient negates the possibility of an equal, consenting relationship.
Therapists who encourage clients to act on these feelings abuse their position of trust.
They misuse the relationship to gratify their own needs, failing to fulfill their
responsibility to help the patient. Such manipulation is a violation of the client's trust
and a form of sexual abuse, even if the client appears to consent or to initiate the
sexual contact.
Many people believe that the power dynamics in the therapeutic
relationship so closely resemble those in the parent-child dyad that sex between therapist
and patient is psychologically equivalent to incest. For this and for other reasons,
several states have criminalized sexual exploitation of patients as a form of statutory
rape.
HOW COMMON IS THERAPIST-PATIENT
SEXUAL EXPLOITATION?
Members of the major mental health
professions have conducted research on the prevalence of psychotherapist-patient sexual
exploitation. These studies show that approximately 7% to 15% of professionals, in
confidential self-reports, admitted to sexual involvement with a client. However, some
researchers believe that the actual incidence may be higher.
WHO EXPLOITS, WHO IS EXPLOITED?
Although the most common pattern involves a
male therapist and a female client, abuse can occur between a therapist and patient of the
same gender, or between a female therapist and a male client. According to one researcher,
80% of offenders exploit more than one patient.
WHAT EFFECT DOES THIS
EXPLOITATION HAVE ON VICTIMS?
Although each person will have a unique
response, common reactions include:
 |
Isolation
|
 |
Confusion about the abuse, about the
perpetrator, and about one's role in the abusive relationship
|
 |
Loss or lessening of ability to trust
|
 |
Feelings of guilt and shame
|
 |
Anger or rage
|
 |
Anxiety and panic
|
 |
Mood swings
|
 |
Depression
|
 |
Suicidal feelings
|
 |
Sexual problems
|
 |
Cognitive problems, such as difficulty
concentrating and intrusive thoughts about the abuse
|
 |
Worsening of the problems for which
client originally sought treatment
|
 |
Reluctance to seek help from another
professional
|
DANGER SIGNALS!
The following behaviors are often
indicators that a sexual boundary violation may be occurring:
 |
Increased or inappropriate therapist
self-disclosure
|
 |
Longer appointments or appointment at end
of day
|
 |
Change of location from a professional
setting to a social setting (e.g., meeting at a restaurant or bar)
|
 |
Introduction of alcohol or misuse of
drugs in treatment
|
 |
Suggestive or seductive statements,
"dirty jokes,'' or other verbally demeaning behavior
|
 |
Bartering for services
|
 |
Therapist intruding into client's
personal life (phone calls at home, social engagements)
|
 |
Excessive or intrusive focus on sexuality
|
 |
Request for secrecy
|
 |
Inappropriate physical contact
|
 |
Nudity
|
 |
Erotic/sexual contact
|
WHAT CAN VICTIMS/SURVIVORS DO IF THEY ARE
SEXUALLY EXPLOITED?
 |
Get out of
the therapy
|
 |
Recognize
that you are not at fault
|
 |
Tell someone
you trust what has happened
|
 |
Share
experiences with other survivors of therapist-client sexual exploitation and/or other
types of sexual abuse; join a support group
|
 |
Report
offender to agency where treatment was provided
|
 |
Report
offender to professional ethics and/or licensing board. (Boards may discipline offender,
may suspend or revoke license to practice.)
|
 |
File a civil
(malpractice) suit. (You can sue for monetary compensation for injury; however, litigation
can be retraumatizing and collecting award may be difficult because of insurance policy
coverage exclusions and economic "caps"
|
 |
File a
criminal complaint. (Depending on the state in which the offense occurred and the specific
details, you may be able to bring criminal charges.)
|
 |
Become
politically active concerning therapist-client sexual exploitation and clients' rights
|
WHAT CAN PROFESSIONALS DO?
 |
Articulate
strict prohibitions against therapist-client sexual involvement.
|
 |
Report
offending colleagues to appropriate boards, and advocate for appropriately strict
discipline for offenders
|
 |
Support
efforts to regulate unlicensed therapists
|
 |
Receive
education on therapist-client sexual exploitation and advocate for including such training
in academic and continuing education programs.
|
 |
Become
politically active concerning therapist-client sexual exploitation and clients' rights
|
 |
Work with
other professionals, consumer-advocates, and survivors to reduce the degree of
retraumatization to survivors who report or litigate
|
SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY
Gabbard, G. (ed.), Sexual Exploitation
in Professional Relationships. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, Inc., 1989.
Pope, K. and Bouhoutsos, J., Sexual Intimacy Between Therapists and
Patients. New York, NY: Praeger, 1986.
Rutter, P., Sex in the Forbidden Zone. Los Angeles, CA: Jeremy
P. Tarcher, Inc., 1989.
Schoener, G. et. al., Psychotherapists' Sexual Involvement with
Clients: Intervention and Prevention. Minneapolis, MN: Walk-In Counseling Center,
1990. (2421 Chicago Avenue South, Minn., MN 55404)
Walker, E. and Young, P. A Killing Cure. New York, NY: Henry
Holt, 1986.
Fact Sheet Prepared By Treatment Exploitation Recovery Network
(TERN).
To contact TERN, please call Sherry at 410-265-6038. |